Back a few months ago, a family member forwarded me a Canadian
Press news release which focused on northern caribou, the primary
topic on the agenda of scientists from around the world who were
meeting in Yellowknife.
I was skimming through the article when a friend popped into the
office to chat about an upcoming moose hunt, so I printed the emailed
article and tossed it on my desk amongst several other papers. Only
recently, as I was flipping through the three-inch pile of notes, trying
to tidy up, did I finally get to read the whole story.
What the report stated came as somewhat of a surprise and I
couldn’t help but compare the situation in that part of the country with
ours here, both on the island and in Labrador, where caribou
populations have plummeted and hunting restrictions have been put in
place.
First a little background: In 2009, nine of Canada’s 11 northern
herds were considered to be in decline. Biologists estimated the
Bathurst population on the central barrens had fallen to 32,000 from
more than 120,000 just three years earlier; a 75 per cent drop.
Preliminary surveys in 2010 and 2011, however, indicate the herd,
as well as the Bluenose East herd, have stabilized or increased, with
numbers in the Bluenose herd back up over 100,000 animals.
Jan Adamczewski, a biologist with the NWT government, said “the
situation overall is looking a lot brighter than it did two years ago... it
kind of looks like maybe we’ve turned the corner there.”
So how, you ask, did this happen?
Surprisingly - to me at least - biologists have no doubt it was
through hunting restrictions. Yes, hunting restrictions.
Climate change and industrial development have been blamed for
some of the decline, but the two biggest factors contributing to the
rebound were calf survival and hunting. Good weather for the last
couple of years has decreased calf mortality, but Adamczewski pointed
out that all the recovering herds have one factor in common - hunting
restrictions.
Adamczewski and three co-authors of a recently-published paper
estimated the annual aboriginal harvest from the Bathurst herd alone
was between 4,000 and 7,000 animals, mostly females.
Resistance to the region’s first-ever hunting controls was strong,
with aboriginal groups taking the government to court and outfitters
taking their own legal action. But in the end, most of the caribou
management boards, composed of government and aboriginal
representatives, brought in restrictions.
Tough decisions had to be made, Adamczewski said, because an
uncontrolled harvest, with hunters using modern high-powered rifles,
snowmobiles and GPS systems, had become one of the biggest factors
in the way of a recovery.
Caribou populations have always fluctuated, he added, but “in the
later stages of the decline, the harvest did start to accelerate the
decline...
“When you look at how quickly things changed once the harvest
was either closed or severely restricted,” he said, “the proof is right
there.”
Something to think about for those who criticize our own
government’s decision in recent years to halt or severely restrict
caribou hunting in Newfoundland and Labrador.